jmb12177 wrote:
If having the flash above the lens is such a bad thing, they why do so many photographers use the hot shoe for a flash that sits above the lens, and not to mention, I have 3 cheap p&s cameras where the flash is not above the lens. Looking at cheap cameras in a store today, I noticed that all the cheap ones do not have a flash above the lens, makes it seem like it is the other way around. Besides, we are trying to be mobile photographers, were not shooting in a studio. Unless you have a way to get a ghost to come in for a studio shoot.
Sent from my 9810 using Tapatalk
If having the flash above the lens is such a bad thing, they why do so many photographers use the hot shoe for a flash that sits above the lens…
Firstly, we’re talking apples and oranges when it comes to a point and shoot and a shoe mounted flash/dlsr combo. The shoe mounted flash has much more punch in power and will yield better results. Some photographers do mount the flash over their cameras [I do on rare occasions when shooting events, but have a diffuser over it], but the photographers at the top of their game use off camera flash [yes, I’m saying that those that use off camera flash are generally better than those who don’t]. A P & S flash will yield harsh straight on light and it’s weak as far as distance goes. With a shoe mounted flash, you can control the power output, the zoom [per the lens zoom range], as well as the equivalent iso speed. Cameras and flashes are dumb, meaning they don’t know what to do unless you tell them. I won’t rely on a dumb piece of technology to give me a hit and a miss in the final image.
I have 3 cheap p&s cameras where the flash is not above the lens. Looking at cheap cameras in a store today, I noticed that all the cheap ones do not have a flash above the lens, makes it seem like it is the other way around.
You’re right many p & s cameras have the flash to the side [I forgot about that, all my P & S for work are above the lens], but the results will be the same due to the proximity of flash/lens location. The flash will be on the lens axis and will still yield less than spectacular results. It’s always better to have the flash fire away from the lens.
Besides, we are trying to be mobile photographers, were not shooting in a studio. Unless you have a way to get a ghost to come in for a studio shoot.
People who use point and shoots really aren’t photographers because they tend to put the camera in auto mode, point, and shoot. There’s more that goes into real photography than pointing and shooting alone [iso speed, aperture, use of additional equipment, etc.]. In the end, it doesn’t matter what camera you use, it’s the spirit who decides if they’re going to be in the shot or not. I myself want the best possible setup in the event that happens. But during an investigation, photography is going to be what I do 95% of the time as the other things don’t interest me. With people like yourself [probably], you’re going to see photography as only a small part compared to everything else you do. With everything else that goes into an investigation, there’s little room or thought to photography. Now, if you want to use the P & S, there are things you can do to improve the shot. You could buy some cheap flashes that have a built in optical slave, so when the flash from the P & S fires, so will the flash(es). That way, the quality of the light will be much better and you won’t have to spend a bunch of unnecessary time trying to analyze a dark photo, because you’ll have plenty of light to see everything in the image. If this is something that may interest you, I can point you to a couple of places. Ebay is great for this, and the flashes are not only cheap, but they’re new. I’ve also done the research and the extra flashes I’ll be getting have gotten good reviews.